Is arthur morgan gay

5/28/ Arthur had a relationship with two women and it's implied that he's attracted to Abigail, so he's certainly not gay. He doesn't show any attraction to any men in the game, so him being bisexual is extremely unlikely. If there's anyone in the gang who is gay/bisexual, it's Bill. 0.

Arthur definitely isn't a sexual person, but he's in no way aromantic. One of the main story arcs in the game is that Arthur Morgan is still in love with Mary Linton, and she has feelings for him as well.